From Our Table to Yours
Maggie’s Complete Easter Dinner Menu
Six beloved family recipes, a make-ahead timeline, and a printable shopping list — everything you need for a joyful Easter celebration.
Easter morning at the Whitaker house starts before the sun does. Jake sets his alarm for 5:30 — the man sleeps through thunderstorms — but on Easter, he’s the one who nudges me awake. “Church,” he says. And I smell coffee already made.
Our Easter dinner isn’t fancy. There’s no tablecloth from Williams Sonoma, no matching china. We have Nana Ruth’s white serving platter (chipped since 1987), a ham that Jake carves standing at the head of the table, and enough food that when his parents drive down from Michigan and Aunt Darlene shows up uninvited with a pie, there’s still plenty. This is part of our bigger Easter recipes collection.
That’s the only rule: there should be more food than people, and more love than food, and nobody should leave the table wishing they’d eaten less or stayed longer. Check out our Easter hub for more celebration ideas too.
Here’s everything we serve — every recipe tested in my kitchen, approved by three children, one husband, one dog, and occasionally Aunt Darlene.
🌙 Saturday Night: Make-Ahead
Start here. The two things you can (and should) make the night before.
Resurrection Morning Cinnamon Rolls
Make these the night before. Wake up to cinnamon filling the house. Jake does the coffee. I do these rolls.
View Recipe →
Make-Ahead Easter Brunch Casserole
Bread, sausage, cheese — layered, refrigerated, baked. You sit with your family for brunch. You actually eat sitting down. It’s a miracle.
View Recipe →
🍴 Easter Dinner: The Main Event
The dish Jake has been carving for twelve years.
🌿 The Sides: Every One Matters
Clara’s deviled eggs disappear first. Every single time.
Nana Ruth’s Deviled Eggs
Clara makes these entirely by herself, standing on her step stool, piping each filling mound like she was born for it. Double the recipe for a crowd.
View Recipe →
Mason’s Spring Garden Salad
Mason picks edible flowers from the garden in rain boots, placing them one petal at a time. Clara makes the lemon vinaigrette. The salad is beautiful.
View Recipe →
🍰 Dessert: The Grand Finale
Jake calls it “the best thing on this table” — every year, and every year he means it.
📅 The Easter Timeline
Thursday / Friday Before
Grocery shop (list below). Hard-boil eggs for deviled eggs — they peel better a day old. Make the Graham cracker crust and refrigerate.
Saturday
Morning: Clara makes Lemon Icebox Pie (needs 4+ hours to set). Afternoon: Prep the ham, make the glaze. Evening: Assemble Cinnamon Rolls and Brunch Casserole — both to the fridge. Clara makes deviled eggs (her job, her timeline, do not interfere).
Easter Sunday Morning
6 AM: Oven on. Cinnamon rolls in. Coffee made. (Jake handles this.) 7 AM: Brunch casserole in. 8 AM: Eat brunch together. Go to church. Breathe.
Easter Sunday Afternoon
1 PM: Ham in the oven (15 min/lb at 325°F). Last 45 min: Three coats of glaze, 15 minutes apart. 30 min before: Mason picks flowers, Clara makes vinaigrette, salad assembled. 4-5 PM: Jake carves. Grace is said. Easter dinner is served.
🛒 Easter Shopping List
Keep this on your fridge starting the week before Easter
Proteins
Bone-in ham (8-10 lbs)
Breakfast sausage (1 lb)
12 large eggs
Dairy
Butter (3 sticks)
Heavy cream
Cream cheese (8 oz)
Sharp cheddar (8 oz)
Milk, Sour cream
Produce
4-5 lemons
Fresh herbs (rosemary, thyme, dill, chives)
Salad greens, snap peas, radishes
Edible flowers, Yellow onion
Pantry & Bread
Honey, Brown sugar, Dijon
Graham crackers, Condensed milk
Flour, Yeast, Cinnamon
Paprika, Pecans, Vanilla
1 loaf sturdy white bread
💜
Why This Menu
The cinnamon rolls are the tradition I almost didn’t start — I cried in the pantry the first time, burned the bottoms, nearly gave up. The ham is Jake teaching Wyatt to carve. The deviled eggs are Clara, claiming a recipe for her own. The salad is Mason choosing flowers like each one matters — because to him, they do.
And the pie is Nana Ruth, still here in faded handwriting, still feeding this family even though she’s been gone five years.
From our table to yours — happy Easter.
I hope your kitchen smells like something good today.
More From Our Kitchen
If you liked this, you might also enjoy:
- Jake’s Bourbon Maple Glazed Easter Ham
- Nana Ruth’s Honey Butter Dinner Rolls
- Clara’s Spring Herb Deviled Eggs
- Nana Ruth’s Hot Cross Bun Bread Pudding
Need a crowd-pleasing appetizer while dinner’s in the oven? Church Potluck Dill Pickle Dip takes five minutes and disappears in ten.
And if you’re looking for something meaningful to start Easter morning before the big meal, try our Resurrection Rolls — the simplest tradition that’s become our family’s favorite.
Join the Kitchen Table
Get Maggie’s newest recipes, seasonal guides, and a little warmth in your inbox. Free, always.
